Faculty Collaboration Database

Modeling the Structure of Acute Sport-Related Concussion Symptoms: A Bifactor Approach. J Int Neuropsychol Soc 2018 Sep;24(8):793-804

Date

08/07/2018

Pubmed ID

30079858

Pubmed Central ID

PMC6589835

DOI

10.1017/S1355617718000462

Scopus ID

2-s2.0-85052685520 (requires institutional sign-in at Scopus site)   17 Citations

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: Concussions cause diverse symptoms that are often measured through a single symptom severity score. Researchers have postulated distinct dimensions of concussion symptoms, raising the possibility that total scores may not accurately represent their multidimensional nature. This study examined to what degree concussion symptoms, assessed by the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 3 (SCAT3), reflect a unidimensional versus multidimensional construct to inform how the SCAT3 should be scored and advance efforts to identify distinct phenotypes of concussion.

METHODS: Data were aggregated across two prospective studies of sport-related concussion, yielding 219 high school and college athletes in the acute (<48 hr) post-injury period. Item-level ratings on the SCAT3 checklist were analyzed through exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses. We specified higher-order and bifactor models and compared their fit, interpretability, and external correlates.

RESULTS: The best-fitting model was a five-factor bifactor model that included a general factor on which all items loaded and four specific factors reflecting emotional symptoms, torpor, sensory sensitivities, and headache symptoms. The bifactor model demonstrated better discriminant validity than the counterpart higher-order model, in which the factors were highly correlated (r=.55-.91).

CONCLUSIONS: The SCAT3 contains items that appear unidimensional, suggesting that it is appropriate to quantify concussion symptoms with total scores. However, evidence of multidimensionality was revealed using bifactor modeling. Additional work is needed to clarify the nature of factors identified by this model, explicate their clinical and research utility, and determine to what degree the model applies to other stages of injury recovery and patient subgroups. (JINS, 2018, 24, 793-804).

Author List

Nelson LD, Kramer MD, Patrick CJ, McCrea MA

Authors

Michael McCrea PhD Professor in the Neurosurgery department at Medical College of Wisconsin
Lindsay D. Nelson PhD Associate Professor in the Neurosurgery department at Medical College of Wisconsin

MESH terms used to index this publication - Major topics in bold

Adolescent
Athletes
Athletic Injuries
Brain Concussion
Emotions
Factor Analysis, Statistical
Female
Headache
Humans
Male
Models, Statistical
Neuropsychological Tests
Phenotype
Prospective Studies
Psychometrics
Sensation
Young Adult